Makeover Fairy

The Makeover Fairy is a character from The Nostalgia Chick portrayed by Elisa Hansen. She has a perky obsession for superficial beauty and fashion, and thus uses her magic to try and make people more "desirable." If her victim proves so homely, that none of her makeover ideas yield an improved appearance, she breaks down and cries.

The Makeover Fairy first appeared in the Chick's Grease review, to grant a wish Lindsay Ellis made for Nella to receive a makeover. She later tried to help convert Dark Nella back to the good side, first by assisting with a seance, then by joining the Newsies-style dance number. When Lindsay reviewed Grease 2, the Makeover Fairy got into the spirit of making over hopeless boys, and tried in vain to make over Lindsay's crush, ToddInTheShadows. She also pushed Lindsay into reviewing every Meg Ryan movie, to compensate for the lack of chick flicks in newer Nostalgia Chick videos.

Sometimes when she appears, the "Makeover" song from Clone High plays.